Ansel removed the feather with a pair of kitchen tongs. He held it at arm's length, like evidence, and dropped it into an envelope.
"It doesn't count," he told me. "I didn't laugh. I made a noise. Noises are not laughs."
"What's the difference?"
"About thirty decibels. And the talkback was off." He sealed the envelope. "Rule four."
"Rule four is that you control the speakers."
"Yes," said Ansel, and for the first time since I'd met him, he cracked his knuckles.
The crickets started in Mitch's dressing room at nine fifteen that morning.
It was one cricket at first: a single, patient chirp every eleven seconds, from somewhere behind the mirror. Mitch took the mirror down, and the chirp moved to the closet. He emptied the closet. The chirp moved to the air vent.
By ten, he was standing on a chair with a flashlight, talking to the vent in the voice he used for Buzz.
"Listen, little buddy. Nobody's mad."
Chirp.
"I'm a little mad."
The cricket, it turned out, was a speaker the size of a quarter. Ansel had wired it into the building's old paging system. That system reached every room on the lot, including two that no longer had doors.
He could move the chirp anywhere from the Pantry. Over the course of the day, he moved it to Mitch's car and the men's room. Finally, he moved it into the back door of the diner set.
During rehearsal, Mitch burst through that door for his entrance. There was a chirp. He forgot his line for the first time in four seasons.
"Note," said Mortimer, from the dark. "Why."
"There's a cricket in the door, Mort."
"Note. There is no cricket in the door."
From the booth came a single, faint chirp. Mitch pointed at the glass. Ansel, behind it, was looking at a waveform with tremendous concentration.
The cast regrouped at craft services. I was there for the coffee. That is my official position and I stand by it.
"He's going to be impossible now," said Benedetta. "On my second show, the editor started a war with the costume department. Two seasons. Somebody lost a horse."
"A real horse?" asked Yasmin.
"Nobody ever found out." Benedetta stirred her tea. "Which tells you something."
Mitch opened his binder on the table. He had divided the war into colored tabs: FEATHERS, SOUND, PSYCHOLOGY. One tab just said HORSE?, which I chose not to ask about.
"The feather worked," he said. "He made the noise, and he was nowhere near touched."
He tapped the page. "Which means it isn't the feather. It's the idea of the feather."
"That's not science," I said. "That's a fortune cookie."
"Switzerland doesn't get a vote," said Mitch. "Benedetta. You're up."
Benedetta Cabrera had been a professional actress for thirty-four years. She had played a nun, a senator, two mothers of the bride, and a ghost who ran a bakery. She understood, better than any of us, the power of doing almost nothing.
At four o'clock, she climbed the stairs to the booth and stood outside the glass.
She didn't knock. She didn't speak. She raised one hand to shoulder height, about ten feet from where Ansel was sitting. She began, very slowly, to wiggle her fingers at him.
That was all. That was the whole prank. A fifty-seven-year-old woman in a diner apron, wiggling her fingers at a pane of glass.
Ansel glanced up and saw her. He looked back down at his screen, then back up. She was still doing it. She raised her other hand and did it with both.
He put his headphones on. She stepped closer to the glass. He turned his chair away. She moved along the window until she was in his eyeline again, wiggling, with the serene face of a woman who had played a nun.
His shoulders began to shake.
He pressed his face into the crook of his elbow. A sound came through the wall. It was muffled by half an inch of glass and three inches of cable-knit, but it was unmistakably the beginning of the Goose.
Benedetta lowered her hands, nodded once, and walked back down the stairs.
"Air tickles," she announced to the stage. "I'm calling them air tickles."
Mitch wrote it in the binder. He underlined it.
Paulette, who had stayed out of the war on professional grounds, picked up a dry-erase marker. Under the faint ghost of GOOSE? on the call sheet whiteboard, she drew a scoreboard.
ENGINEER — LAUGHS ON TALKBACK: 0 DAYS TO FINALE: 16
"Fifteen," she said, to nobody. "By tonight, fifteen."
I want to be clear that the retaliation was fair. It all fell under rule four.
On Monday, Yasmin opened a bag of rice crackers at lunch. Every bite came out of the stage speakers at the volume of a building being demolished. She took one bite, froze, and looked up at the booth. Ansel raised his coffee to her.
She tried a banana. The speakers played the sound of a banana being peeled, slowed down by a factor of ten, so it sounded like a ship running aground. She laughed so hard she had to sit down on the diner floor.
On Tuesday, Benedetta made her entrance in rehearsal. Normally the stage speakers played a warm round of applause for her, as a joke, because she liked it. This time they played a single person clapping, very slowly, from what sounded like a parking garage.
She stopped at her mark. She looked at the booth.
"Thirty-four years," she said, to the ceiling.
The slow clap continued, and then, very faintly, a single cricket.
But the cast was getting closer, and everyone could tell.
Yasmin mailed him a feather. She actually mailed it, to the studio, with a stamp.
He opened the envelope at his desk. Inside was a slip of paper that said MADE YOU LOOK, and no feather at all. He made the noise anyway, from the pure anticipation of a feather. He told me afterward that it was the worst prank of all, because there was nothing to blame.
Mitch rigged a leaf blower in the lighting grid. When Ansel came down the stairs for lunch, it released two hundred feathers from the ceiling of the stage. They drifted down over the diner set, over the bleachers, over everything. Every one of them landed at least six feet from Ansel.
Mitch had measured with a tape.
Ansel stood at the bottom of the stairs and watched them come down around him. He did not move. A single feather landed on the step in front of his shoe. He looked at it for a long time.
Then he turned around, walked back up to the booth, and closed the door. Through the glass, we watched him put his forehead on the mixing desk.
The talkback light stayed dark. The scoreboard stayed at zero.
"He's muting himself," said Mitch, with real admiration. "He's laughing with the talkback off. That's cheating."
"That's rule four," said Paulette. "Eleven days."
The war ended, briefly, on Wednesday afternoon.
Mortimer called everybody to the diner set. The bleachers were still full of feathers, so we stood. He waited until we were quiet, which took a while, because Yasmin had found a cracker.
"Note," he said. "Everybody stop."
We stopped.
"The network called." He looked at all of us in turn.
"They want the finale live. East Coast feed. Real time. Nine p.m., from this stage, in front of the audience."
Nobody said anything. Somewhere in the bleachers, a feather settled.
"There's an executive flying in, Renata Abbott. She's fifty-two and has never laughed at a pilot."
He let that land. "She'll be in the third row. Season five depends on that night."
Mortimer removed his glasses, which nobody had ever seen him do. "Note. Live means live. No second takes, no sweetening."
He looked up at the booth. Ansel looked back at him through the glass.
"Every laugh that goes out that night," said Mortimer, "is whatever laugh is in the room."
Ansel pushed up his glasses with one knuckle. Then he looked over at the Pantry, and at his four thousand laughs, and I could see him doing the math.
That should have been the end of it. Mortimer had said stop. Paulette erased the scoreboard, or tried to. It came off about as well as GOOSE? had.
But after the meeting, while the grips swept feathers off the bleachers, I found Mitch's binder.
He had left it on the craft services table, next to the coffee urn. TAXES. Nobody ever opens a binder labeled taxes.
I opened it.
The last tab was new, and red. Inside was a single page with a hand-drawn diagram of the booth, the bleachers, and the lighting grid.
Arrows ran from the grid to the booth window. Three of them were labeled FEATHERS. One was labeled VINCE.
Across the top, in block capitals, Mitch had written: FINALE NIGHT — OPERATION GOOSE.
At the bottom of the page was a list of names. Benedetta. Yasmin. Paulette, with a question mark.
The last name on the list was mine. Next to it, Mitch had written: JO — THE BOOM.
Up next: Strike
Continue to Part 4 →