Dr. Theo Marchetti kept his pebbles in the drawer where a normal dentist keeps the fluoride trays.
I found this out on my second day at Marchetti Family Dentistry, when I went looking for fluoride trays. I was thirty-three, a hygienist with nine years of experience. I had worked in four practices and opened a lot of drawers.
None of them had ever contained forty-one small stones, each one sitting in its own labeled compartment like a jewel in a museum nobody visits.
The drawer had forty-two compartments. One was empty.
I closed it very gently, the way you close a door on someone praying.
I estimate things in minutes. It is my one skill outside of teeth.
If a patient says, "Can I ask you something quick?" I know it will take eleven minutes. If a man starts a sentence with "So, my wife thinks," I block out twenty. I have never been wrong by more than three.
I estimated that the story behind the pebble drawer would take four minutes. It took two years.
The short version is this. Theo runs races, all of them. Fun runs, 5Ks, half-marathons, a charity relay where the baton was a rubber chicken. He runs them without shoes.
At the end of each one, he picks up one pebble from the course. He writes the race and his time on a tiny label. Then he brings it back to the drawer.
"Why?" I asked him, that first week.
He was eating a granola bar over the sink, because he believed crumbs were a moral failing. He was thirty-nine, tall and narrow, with sandy hair that refused every instruction he gave it. He wore the same gray cardigan every day over his scrubs. He owned, I later learned, four of them.
"The road keeps a receipt," he said.
"I'm sorry?"
"You pay for every mile. The pebble is the receipt."
He finished the granola bar and folded the wrapper into a perfect square. "My father was an accountant. He never believed anything without a receipt."
That was the entire explanation. I waited for more. Theo washed his hands for exactly twenty seconds and went to see his ten-thirty.
Here is what you need to know about Theo Marchetti as a dentist. He is excellent, gentle and patient. He explains everything twice, once in dental and once in English.
Children love him. Elderly men who have not been to a dentist since the Carter administration love him.
Here is what you need to know about Theo Marchetti as a person. He is the most stubborn man in Calder Falls.
He does not argue. That would be easier. He agrees with you completely, nods, says, "That's a very good point," and then does exactly what he was going to do. Our receptionist, Marguerite, calls it "the polite brick wall."
Marguerite was sixty-six and had run the front desk for twenty-three years, through two previous dentists and one flood. She ran a betting pool on the whiteboard behind reception. It was supposed to list the day's appointments. Instead it listed odds.
On my first Monday, the whiteboard read:
MR. FENWICK FLOSSED THIS MONTH: 9 to 1 DR. B WEARS SHOES TO THE HOLIDAY PARTY: 40 to 1 NEW GIRL LASTS A YEAR: 3 to 1
"I'm the new girl," I said.
"You are," Marguerite agreed. "Don't take it personally. The last one lasted four months. She opened the drawer."
"I opened the drawer."
Marguerite looked at me over her reading glasses with new respect. She picked up the marker and changed my odds to 2 to 1.
Theo was not a hippie about it, which surprised me. I had assumed a shoeless runner would talk about energy, or the earth, or ancestors. He did not. He found that kind of talk embarrassing.
His position was practical and slightly cranky. Shoes, he said, let you stop paying attention.
You can run a whole race in shoes and not know what it was made of. Without them, you have to read the road. Every crack, every bottle cap, every acorn.
"It's like flossing," he told me once. "Nobody wants to. That's why it works."
"That's not what flossing is like."
"It's exactly what flossing is like."
I did not win that argument. I want to be clear that nobody has ever won an argument with Theo. You just eventually notice that you are holding the floss.
He took sensible care of himself. He trained on the track at the community college.
He saw a sports doctor twice a year, a brisk woman who called him "my problem child." He had never had a serious injury. He seemed to regard this less as luck than as the natural result of paying attention.
The drawer had a system.
Each pebble had a label in Theo's tiny, careful handwriting. The labels said things like RIVERFRONT 10K, 51:14 and TURKEY TROT, 26:02, RAINED. One said BAKERY DASH, 24:40, ATE A SCONE AT MILE 2.
Pebble number seventeen had a different label. It was flatter than the others, dark gray and slightly glossy. The label read BIRCH HOLLOW 5K, 23:51. DISPUTED.
"Disputed by who?" I asked.
"By me," Theo said. "It isn't really a pebble."
"What is it?"
"It's a grievance." He closed the drawer. "Your two o'clock is here."
I filed that away. I file a lot of things away. Most of them turn out to be nothing. That one turned out to be about forty thousand dollars and a city council meeting, but I didn't know that yet.
The empty compartment belonged to the Calder Falls Marathon.
It was the only race in the county Theo had never run. For seven years, something had always gone wrong.
One year he had the flu. One year a patient cracked a molar on a peach pit the night before. One year the race was cancelled for a thunderstorm that never actually arrived.
"When the drawer is full," Theo said, "I'm done."
Marguerite heard this from reception. She wrote on the whiteboard:
DR. B ACTUALLY RETIRES FROM RUNNING: 50 to 1
"You don't believe me," Theo said.
"I believe you believe it," said Marguerite. "That's different. That's worth about fifty to one."
The other person who did not believe him was Craig Pell. Craig owned Stride Theory, the running store on Fourth Street. He was forty-four, very tan, with a whistle around his neck that he never used.
Craig went to every race in the county. He went to every race Theo ran. At the start of every one, he walked up to Theo and held out a shoebox.
"Size eleven," Craig would say. "Whenever you're ready."
"Thank you, Craig," Theo would say. "Not today."
They had done this forty-one times. I saw it at my first race as a spectator, the Riverfront Fall Classic.
Craig had the box tucked under his arm like a football. Theo declined it with the warmth of a man turning down a second helping. Craig nodded, unbothered, and went back to his tent.
"Does he ever get annoyed?" I asked Craig afterward.
"Annoyed?" Craig looked genuinely puzzled. "I'm not annoyed, I'm patient. Retail is a long game."
By my second September at Marchetti Family Dentistry, everything was ready for the marathon.
Theo had trained for nine months. He had a spreadsheet. He had studied the course map until he could recite it. Twenty-six point two miles, starting at the river, looping through downtown, out along Old Mill Road, and back across the Juniper Street bridge.
Old Mill Road was his favorite part. Six miles of smooth, gray, ancient asphalt, worn soft by forty years of farm trucks.
"It's like running on a library table," he said.
Marguerite's odds on the whiteboard read:
DR. B FINISHES THE MARATHON: 4 to 1 SOMETHING GOES WRONG AGAIN: 6 to 5
"That's insulting," Theo said.
"That's math," said Marguerite.
The marathon was on a Sunday, the twenty-sixth of October.
On the second of October, a Thursday, I was eating lunch at my desk and scrolling the city website. I do this sometimes. Municipal websites are very calming. Nobody on them is ever in a hurry.
There was a new notice on the Public Works page.
PUBLIC NOTICE: ROADWAY PRESERVATION PROJECT
The City of Calder Falls will apply a chip seal surface treatment to Old Mill Road between Hutchins Lane and the county line, beginning Monday, October 6. Chip seal is a cost-effective method of extending pavement life using a layer of fresh aggregate (gravel).
Residents may notice loose gravel for several weeks.
We thank you for your patience!
I read it twice. Then I counted on my fingers. Three weeks and three days.
I estimated that telling Theo would take nine minutes. I walked down the hall to his office, where he was eating a second granola bar over his wastebasket.
I showed him my phone.
He read it once. He did not swear. Theo never swears. He set the granola bar down on a napkin, folded the napkin around it, and stood up.
"Rosa," he said. "What do I have Thursday afternoon?"
"Today is Thursday."
"Next Thursday."
I checked. "Eleven patients. Including Mrs. Albescu's crown."
"Move them."
"All eleven?"
"Mrs. Albescu can come Friday. She says the drill sounds friendlier on Fridays." He pulled his cardigan off the back of his chair. "Next Thursday, I'm going to City Hall."
From reception, I heard the squeak of a whiteboard marker.
It had taken ninety seconds. I had been wrong by seven and a half minutes. In nine years, it was the first time I had been wrong by more than three.
Up next: Public Comment
Continue to Part 2 →