Eight days before clips.com expired, Otis Fairweather sat at our father's kitchen table and told us we didn't own it yet.
Otis had played chess with Dad every Thursday for thirty years. He was a retired surveyor with enormous ears and a cardigan the color of wet sand. He brought his own thermos everywhere, filled with coffee so weak it was more of a rumor.
He also, it turned out, was the executor of the will.
"Not us?" Gunnar said. "Not one of his kids?"
"He said you'd argue," Otis said. "He said I'd be neutral. I told him nobody's neutral."
He poured himself a cup of the rumor. "He said I'm the closest thing in Asker Lake. Then he took my bishop."
The will was short. The house, the savings, and the store's remaining inventory went to the three of us, equally. The truck went to Otis. He said that was fair, because he'd been lending Dad his snowblower since 2004.
Then there was a separate paragraph. Otis read it out in his surveyor's voice, the one that measured every word.
"'The domain clips.com passes to my three children jointly. My executor will hold a sealed envelope. He will open it only when all three have decided, together, what to do with clips.com. He will sign nothing for the registrar until they do.'"
He put the paper down.
"Together," Teddy repeated.
"That's the word he used."
"And if we don't decide?"
Otis shrugged. "Then it expires. And I keep the envelope."
The registrar was a company called Nameplate Registry. Their phone line opened with a recording that thanked us for choosing Nameplate, as if we had. Then came the hold music.
It was a pan flute version of something that might once have been a song. Teddy, who mixes audio for a living, listened to eleven seconds of it and put her head on the table.
"Someone recorded that on purpose," she said. "Someone was paid."
After nineteen minutes, a young man came on the line. His name was Desmond. He sounded about twenty-nine and very sincere.
"I'm so sorry for your loss," he said, and he meant it, which was somehow worse.
I explained. Desmond typed. His keyboard sounded like rain on a carport.
"Okay, so, clips.com," he said. "Wow. That's a really clean name. Like, really clean."
"So we've heard."
"Five letters, real word, dot com. People would, um. People would want that."
"How much would they want it?" Gunnar asked.
"I'm not allowed to give valuations, sir." Desmond lowered his voice, as if his supervisor lived in the keyboard. "But I've worked here four years. I've never seen one this clean that wasn't a company."
Teddy wrote something on a label. She didn't show anyone.
"Can we renew it?"
"The account's in your father's name. I can't change anything without the executor's paperwork. The renewal has to come from the account, or from the executor."
"And if it lapses?"
He paused. I could hear him deciding whether to be honest.
"There's a grace period. Then a redemption period. Then it drops."
Another pause. "Names like clips.com get caught by backorder services in about four seconds. You wouldn't get it back. Nobody would sell it to you for less than a house."
I thanked him. He said he'd put a note on the account. He said, "Again, I'm really sorry."
Then the pan flute came back for one second before the line went dead. It wanted the last word.
We sat at the kitchen table with the binder between us. The burn mark shaped like Ohio was in the middle, where it had always been.
"It's simple," Gunnar said. "We sell. We split it three ways. Dad would want us taken care of."
"Dad wrote NO in red marker," Teddy said. "In capital letters. He never used capital letters for anything except paint."
"He was a seventy-two-year-old man who didn't understand what he had."
"He understood it enough to say no."
"He understood thirty-five dollars a year." Gunnar spread his hands. "Let's be realistic. None of us can build anything on it."
He counted us off on his fingers. "Teddy, you record radio. Maren estimates hail damage. I straighten teeth."
"Then why did he keep it?" Teddy said.
Nobody answered. That was the problem. Everybody had an answer for what to do, and nobody had one for why.
Then they both turned and looked at me.
I knew the look. I'd been the swing vote in this kitchen since I was thirteen.
Whose turn for dishes. Who got the front seat. Whether Gunnar was really sick or just had a chemistry test.
Somebody had to decide, and Dad was usually at the store.
"I don't know yet," I said.
"Maren." Gunnar used the voice he probably used with patients who wanted the colored bands. "You price things for a living. Price this."
He wasn't wrong. That was what bothered me. The appraiser in me had already started. Comparable sales, five-letter dot-coms, the Corvane letter as a floor.
But I'd been trained never to appraise something before I knew what it was. And I had no idea what clips.com was.
"Eight days," I said. "Give me eight days."
Sloane Achterberg emailed within the hour.
I don't know how she found us. Possibly the obituary. Possibly Corvane had a system that watched for people's fathers to die. The email went to all three of us, which meant she'd done research.
Dear Brekke family,
Please accept my sincere condolences. I had the privilege of speaking with your father many times. I would welcome a brief call at your convenience.
Warmly,
Sloane
"Warmly," Teddy said. "She sent a vulture email and signed it 'warmly.'"
"She's being professional," Gunnar said, and called her.
He put her on speaker. Sloane answered from what was clearly an airport. A gate announcement for Denver played behind her the whole time. Then one for Atlanta, then Denver again, as if she flew in circles.
"I'm so glad you called," she said. Her voice was bright and smooth, like a well-kept hotel lobby. "Your father was a remarkable man. Very firm."
"He said no to you," Teddy said.
"He did. Every March, for seven years." She didn't sound offended. She sounded fond.
"I'd call," she went on. "We'd talk about the weather. I'd make an offer. He'd say no, then ask how my mother's hip was doing."
Gunnar leaned toward the phone. "What's the offer now?"
"For clips.com, today?" A short pause. "Two million six hundred thousand."
Gunnar sat back. Teddy stared at the burn mark. I priced the silence. It was expensive.
"I'd need an answer before the name expires, obviously," Sloane added. "After that it's an open market. I can't promise anything."
"Can I ask you something?" I said. "When he said no. Did he ever say why?"
"Not really. He wasn't a man of long explanations." Sloane laughed softly.
"But he always said the same thing," she said. "Every single year. I wrote it down once, because it was so odd."
"What did he say?"
Behind her, Denver was boarding again.
"He said, 'It isn't mine to sell.'"
That night I couldn't sleep, so I did what I do when I can't sleep. I worked.
I sat at Dad's computer with a legal pad and looked up every five-letter dot-com sale I could find. Most were companies with logos and lawyers. A few were just words, sold quietly between people who wore vests.
By two in the morning, I had a range. It was a large range. Sloane's number sat near the bottom of it.
Teddy came down at 2:15 in a sweatshirt that said WKRP STAFF, which she had bought ironically and now wore sincerely. She read my legal pad over my shoulder.
"You're appraising it," she said.
"I'm gathering information."
"You're appraising Dad's mystery at two in the morning." She didn't say it unkindly. She said it like Aunt Solveig, which was worse.
"Somebody has to know what it's worth," I said.
"Somebody has to know what it is." She pulled the MYSTERY label off the monitor and stuck it on my legal pad, right over the number. Then she went back upstairs.
I looked at the label for a long time. Estimated value: about four cents. It covered three million dollars completely.
Up next: Theories
Continue to Part 3 →