On my first visit to Margo Iverson's house, I stopped at a strip of brass in her front hall. I asked if it was a heating vent.
"It's the line," she said.
I looked down at it. It was a quarter inch wide and ran wall to wall, set flush into the oak floor. Somebody had polished it recently. Possibly that morning.
"What happens at the line?" I asked.
"Shoes," she said. "They stop."
I was thirty-two at the time, and I taught earth science at Hollis Creek Middle School. I had spent eight years in rooms where forty sixth-graders shared one cubby wall and a single lost-and-found bin. I had never met anyone who had drawn a border on a floor.
I took my shoes off and put them in the wooden cubby by the door. When I came back from the kitchen, they had been turned around. Both of them now faced the door, heels to the wall, as if they were waiting for a bus.
I assumed this was decorative. I was wrong about that, and about a lot of things, for fourteen months.
Margo was thirty, and she restored old floors for a living. Her company was called Iverson Floor & Finish. It consisted of Margo, a used van, and a sander she called Doris. I never learned why.
She had bought the house, a 1924 bungalow on Fallow Street, at twenty-seven. The floors had been under carpet since the Carter administration. She spent two years pulling staples and sanding, mostly at night after her paid jobs. The result was quarter-sawn oak the color of strong tea.
So at first I understood the line as a craftsman protecting her work. A painter doesn't let people lean on wet canvas.
But it showed up in the details.
There was the basket. It sat on a bench beside the cubby and held guest slippers, gray felt with leather bottoms. Each pair had a small hand-lettered tag: 6, 7, 8, all the way up to 13.
And at the very bottom, one more pair. Enormous. Tagged MYSTERY — 14.
"Who's that for?" I asked, on my second visit.
"The guest I haven't met yet," she said.
"Do you know anyone who wears a fourteen?"
"No," she said. "That's why it's a mystery."
There were other rules, and none were written down. Coats went on the hooks, never on chairs.
Groceries came in through the side door, and the bags never touched the kitchen floor. Margo vacuumed on Tuesdays and Saturdays. In between, she kept a cordless unit charged the way other people keep a phone charged.
My friend Rudy, who is forty and plays trombone in a wedding band, came over once for dinner. He kept his shoes on for one step. Margo didn't say a word. She looked at the shoes, then at the line, then at him.
He took them off so fast he nearly fell over.
"She didn't even say anything," he told me later, in the car.
"She doesn't have to."
"It's like being looked at by a crossing guard," Rudy said. "A crossing guard who knows where you live."
My family is a shoes-on family. I want to be clear about that, because it matters later.
My mother, Patrice Haverford, is sixty-one. She wears shoes in her own house from the moment she gets up. She says it is because of her arches. She says this about most things.
She also cooks for every holiday as if the Army might stop by. She names her casseroles after whoever first gave her the recipe. There is a Bernice. There is a Pastor Gene, which has water chestnuts in it, and nobody has ever asked why.
My father, Vern Haverford, is sixty-four and retired after thirty-one years as a letter carrier. He judges a house by its front steps. He has opinions about mailbox heights that he will share whether or not you have a mailbox.
And he has one line he has said at every family gathering of my life.
"Thirty-one years carrying mail," he says, usually while someone's dog is looking at him. "Never once took my shoes off in somebody's house."
I told Margo this early, the way you warn someone about a step that's higher than it looks.
"He'll take them off," she said.
"He won't."
"Everybody takes them off." She said it the way other people say the sun comes up.
My sister Gwen is twenty-seven and a veterinary technician. She owns a 120-pound Newfoundland mix named Tugboat, who looks like a black rug that learned to walk. When Tugboat chews a couch, Gwen says he is "working through something." When he ignores a command, he is "processing."
That was my family. For fourteen months, I had kept them and Margo's house in separate parts of my life.
Then my parents' kitchen fell through their basement ceiling.
It was not a dramatic collapse. A pipe under the sink had been leaking since roughly June. The subfloor gave up the week before Halloween. My father described it as "the dishwasher going downstairs to live with the furnace."
Thanksgiving had been at my parents' house for thirty-four years. Now it had nowhere to go.
"We could do a restaurant," I said to Margo that night.
She was sitting on her living room floor. That is where she sits. She says couches are for people who don't trust their floors.
"I'll host," she said.
"Margo."
"I want to meet them properly. In my house." She paused. "With the line."
"My father has never taken his shoes off in a house."
"Then he's never been in mine."
I should have argued more. I didn't. Partly because she wore the look she gets when a board won't sit flat and she's decided it will. And partly because of the small velvet box in my coat pocket.
I had bought the ring in September. I had carried it for six weeks, waiting for the right moment. My plan was simple and probably terrible: Thanksgiving, pie, my whole family at one table. I would stand up and ask.
Now the table would be hers. It felt like a sign.
The second sign arrived the following Monday, from the Hollis County Fire Marshal's Office.
In August, Margo had applied for a permit to run her business out of her detached garage. She stored stains and sealers there, and the county had to inspect before it signed off. Her biggest job of the year depended on it. In January she was restoring the reading-room floor at the old Corning Street library, and the contract required a permitted shop.
Two inspection dates had already been canceled. The letter announced the third. She read it aloud at her kitchen counter.
"Your inspection has been assigned to Thursday, November 26, between noon and five. Please ensure clear access to all areas." She set it down. "That's Thanksgiving."
"Call them."
She called. A woman named Corinna told her the next opening was the second week of February.
"So we cancel Thanksgiving," I said.
"We don't cancel Thanksgiving." She picked up the letter and read the last line twice. "'The inspector will be in full uniform.'"
"That probably just means a jacket."
She looked at the cubby. She looked at the line.
"Probably," she said.
On Thanksgiving morning I got to Margo's at seven. She had been up since five. The house smelled like sage and floor polish, which in that house counted as a holiday scent.
I hung up my coat. Then I stood in the front hall with the ring box in my hand and realized I had nowhere to put it.
My coat was out, because Margo straightened coats. My pockets were out, because a velvet box is not subtle in corduroys. Margo knew every inch of that house the way a pilot knows a cockpit.
Except one place.
She never reached inside a guest's shoes. She turned them to face the door, and that was all. Shoes were the outside world, and she did not reach into the outside world.
So I slid the box deep inside my left boot, in the cubby. Then I turned the boot back to face the door, the way she liked it.
I went into the kitchen to peel potatoes. For about forty minutes, I felt like a genius.
At 7:52 my phone buzzed. It was Gwen.
On our way at 11, bringing Tugboat, he gets sad alone on holidays. Fair warning, he takes shoes. Only the left one, we don't know why. He's processing.
I read it twice. Then I looked down the hall at the cubby, where my left boot sat facing the door, waiting for a ride.
Up next: Under Protest
Continue to Part 2 →