Three days after Mavis Rusk's jacket disappeared, Clifford Penrose stood in the workroom doorway holding a library book and a folded note. The note said FOR THE LADY IN THE JACKET. Clifford's hands, which had never once shaken over a form, were shaking.
Mavis took the note from him. She did not open it right away. She looked at the handwriting first, the way she'd look at a call number.
"Block capitals," she said. "Fountain pen. Someone taught him penmanship with a ruler."
Then she unfolded it and read it out loud. She was a librarian, and that's what you do with a text in a room full of people.
To the Lady in the Jacket,
I have taken your jacket. I apologize for the method. The left elbow seam is going and the zipper is a disgrace.
I have watched it from the bus stop for a month, getting worse. I could not stand it any longer.
I will have it back to you by Thursday, good as new. Better than new, frankly. New was not that good.
I meant to ask you properly at the desk. I lost my nerve, on account of the enclosed. I am returning it with my apologies. They are thirty-nine years overdue, like the book.
Respectfully, A.P.
Nobody said anything. Rollo, who was standing in the workroom with the dictionary, stopped whistling at bar two.
"A.P.," I said. "Like the collar."
"Like the collar," Mavis said.
She turned the book over. It was a thin orange hardback called Small Engines and the People Who Love Them, published in 1979. The spine had been mended once with tape. The tape had been mended once with more tape.
Inside the back cover was the old paper pocket and the old card. Most of it was faded. The due date stamp wasn't. It read OCT 23 1987 in purple ink.
Below the stamp, in tiny cramped letters, were the initials of the clerk who'd checked it out. M.R.
Mavis put one fingertip on them.
"That's me," she said. "That's my first stamp. My very first day on the bookmobile."
"You remember?"
"I remember everyone from that week. I was terrified. I memorized faces so I'd have something to do with my hands."
She closed her eyes. "Route 9, the stop by the docks. A man in a hat."
"He'd sold me this jacket two days before. He came to the bookmobile to see whether it fit."
"Did it?"
"He said the shoulders were right and the attitude needed time." She opened her eyes. "He took out a book on small engines. He said he was going to rebuild a motorcycle in his garage."
"And he never brought it back."
"Overdue," said Mavis. But she said it softly, as if it were a person's name.
Clifford had been holding his clipboard against his chest like a shield.
"By policy," he said, "this is a theft. A theft with a confession. Technically, the confession should go on its own form."
"It's a repair," Mavis said.
"Without consent."
"Clifford." She held up the note. "He said please. In fountain pen."
Officer Quarles arrived at two. He read the note twice, his lips moving at "New was not that good." Then he closed his notebook and put it in his pocket.
"Ms. Rusk," he said. "Do you want to press charges?"
"I want my jacket."
"Then this isn't a theft. It's a house call."
He nodded at Clifford. "File it however you want, sir. I'm writing 'resolved, pending zipper.'"
Clifford actually smiled. I wrote that down later. It's the only record of it I know of.
There was still one problem. Nobody knew where A.P. lived.
The book card said only A. PRENTISS, and under it an address on Dock Street. That was the old Osprey building, now loft apartments with a doorman who'd never heard of anybody.
"Phone book," Rollo said.
"They stopped printing phone books, Rollo."
"That's a shame. They were good for doors."
I ran his name through every database the branch could reach. I found three A. Prentisses in the county.
One was a dental hygienist named Alyssa. One was a dog groomer named Amber. One was a parakeet named Admiral, registered at a veterinary clinic. None of them sounded like they had ever rebuilt a motorcycle.
Then Clifford did something I'd never seen anyone do in four years. He walked into his office and opened the gray cabinet.
We followed him. All of us. It felt like watching someone open a tomb.
The cabinet held exactly what you would hope and fear. Every third copy of every form he had filed in nineteen years, in order. And on the bottom shelf, under a sheet of plastic, a row of thick green ledgers.
"Circulation ledgers," Clifford said. "Nineteen eighty-two through two thousand four. Central was going to shred them during the computer switch."
"You saved them," Mavis said.
"I filed a form objecting to the shredding. Nobody answered the form, so I kept them until somebody did."
He cleared his throat. "Nobody did. It's been twenty-two years. I check the mail every day."
He found 1987 in under a minute and ran a finger down October.
There it was, in Mavis's own twenty-two-year-old handwriting: Prentiss, August. Small Engines and the People Who Love Them. The work address was Osprey. But beside it, in parentheses, she had written a second address. Home: 31 Tanner Lane.
"Why did you write his home address?" I asked.
"Because I was twenty-two and thorough," Mavis said. "I was afraid of losing anything. Even a small engines book."
"So you've been like this since day one."
"I've been like this since before day one. Day one just gave me a stamp."
I did one last thing before we left. I pulled up Sully's broadcast feed, where people had spent all morning posting photos of Mavis in the jacket over the years.
There were hundreds. Mavis at the 1999 book sale. Mavis on the bookmobile in snow.
Mavis judging a library pumpkin-carving contest in 2014, looking disappointed in a pumpkin. Mavis in the background of somebody's wedding photo, because the reception had been next door.
And Mavis on the bench outside the branch, eating lunch, from just three weeks ago. A patron had snapped it for a library appreciation post.
In the far corner, across the street at the Route 9 bus stop, sat an old man in a gray felt hat. He had a sketchbook on his knee. He was drawing something, and he was looking right at her left elbow.
"Thirty-nine years in the same jacket," I said. "Everyone in the city has a picture of it."
"It was never a disguise," Mavis said. "It was a landmark."
Tanner Lane was a short street of brick storefronts behind the fish market. Mavis, Clifford and I took Clifford's car, which smelled of toner and had a first-aid kit in triplicate.
Rollo stayed to run the desk, armed with the dictionary. We told nobody else. Mavis was firm about that.
"No radio, no Riders, no ticket dispenser," she said. "He wrote me a letter. I'm answering it in person."
Clifford drove exactly the speed limit the whole way. At every stop sign he came to a full stop and counted to two.
"What are you going to say to him?" I asked Mavis.
"I've been drafting it since the ledger," she said. "So far I have 'Hello' and 'Where is my jacket.' I'm working on the transition."
"I could bring a form," Clifford offered. "For structure."
"Clifford," Mavis said, "you are a good man and a fine manager. No."
It was the first compliment any of us had heard her pay him in nineteen years. Clifford drove the rest of the way in a silence so happy it fogged the windshield.
Number 31 was the last shop on the block. The front window was painted in old gold letters: PRENTISS REPAIR — LEATHER, CANVAS, SADDLERY. A cardboard sign on the door said CLOSED. It looked like it had said CLOSED for years and had stopped arguing about it.
But there was a light on in the back.
And under the hum of traffic from the fish market, faint and steady, we could hear an old sewing machine running.
Mavis stepped up to the window. She cupped her hands against the glass. Then she went completely still.
Inside, on a battered dress form in the middle of the room, under a single hanging lamp, was her jacket.
Up next: Fine Waived
Continue to Part 6 →